ClockPlayEmailInstagramLinkSMSTwitterYouTubeWhatsAppXSearchClockRight ArrowArrow DownCaret downCaret upCaret leftCaret rightHamburger MenuPop OutThumbs upThumbs up buySpeechAudio onReplayPlusMinusSad smiley faceNo resultsSwapMoreYour grocery bagSuccessShop Tasty MerchYour Cart (empty)Your CartFacebookPinterestEmailPrintSmsTwitterWhatsappCommentTips Highlights
Skip to Content

"It Tastes Like Nothing And Feels Like Wax In Your Mouth": People Are Sharing Unpopular Food Opinions, And I'm Curious If You Agree With Any Of Them

"Pickles are disgusting. I hate when restaurants sneak them into a plate so my sandwich or fries are suddenly sitting in salty, green sludge."

There's a reason that they make chocolate and vanilla. People have wildly different preferences when it comes to food, of course. But every now and then, you hear an unpopular culinary opinion that truly shocks you. So redditor u/xSurpriseShawtyx asked, "What’s your controversial food opinion?" Here's some of what people said.

1. "Hot sauce doesn't add adds heat, which makes good food taste like nothing but the spicy hot sauce. No hot sauce for me, please."

Close-up of fried eggs with spicy hot sauce being poured on top

2. "Scrambled eggs are best when they're overcooked. I like them firm, toothsome, and a little bit browned. Many celebrity chefs' scrambled egg recipes that I see show the eggs being 'done' when they're still wildly undercooked — loose, glossy, gloopy-looking. Yuck. Give me my burnt eggs."

Well-cooked scrambled eggs

3. "The cookie part of the Oreo is way better than the filling."

An Oreo cookie broken apart

4. "Chocolate pieces in ice cream taste like nothing and feel like wax in your mouth."

Mint chocolate chip ice cream in waffle cone

5. "I resent food. I honestly don't like eating every day. I'd switch to photosynthesis if humanly possible."

A woman eating Asian fast food from a cardboard box

6. "I love to eat lemons the way that most people eat oranges. People act like it's crazy, but it’s normal to eat citrus and normal to enjoy sour why is it abnormal to eat a sour citrus?"

A person holding half a lemon

7. "Cheese belongs on pretty much everything, including seafood. Whoever said not to mix seafood and cheese has clearly never tried Parmesan-crusted scallops, lobster mac 'n' cheese, or shrimp Parmesan, just for starters. Totally delightful."

Shrimp and cheesy grits

8. "It's a travesty that 'vanilla' is a word used to describe bland or unexciting things. The real thing has such a unique flavor — not to mention, it's actually very expensive, up there with saffron."

Vanilla ice cream

9. "We put way too much pressure on cauliflower to be things that aren’t cauliflower."

Buffalo cauliflower bites with blue cheese dressing and celery

10. "Pickles are disgusting. I hate when restaurants sneak them into a plate so my sandwich or fries are suddenly sitting in salty, green sludge. For the love of God, hold the damn pickles."

A Reuben sandwich with a pickle

11. "Plain Greek yogurt can replace sour cream in literally any recipe and taste indistinguishable or better."

Chicken salad on toast

12. "Avocados are overrated. I hate the texture and taste of them. They're like grass-flavored play dough."

Mashed avocado toast

13. "Let's call it what it is: Meal prepping is just a nicer way of saying you're eating leftovers all week."

Glass containers of cooked food

14. "The McRib really should stop coming back."

A McRib sandwich from McDonald's

15. "Crab is better than lobster. Lobster has always tasted like a less delicious crab dish to me, no matter how expensive, fresh, or well prepared it is."

A lobster roll with potatoes and slaw

16. "Sandwiches overstuffed with meat are usually very low quality and screw up the whole bread-to-meat-to-vegetables ratio that makes a sandwich enjoyable in the first place."

A halved Italian combo sandwich

17. "Leftover pizza reheated in the microwave is even better than fresh pizza. Frozen, delivery, homemade doesn’t matter. Microwaved pizza gets soggy and floppy, just the way I like it."

Leftover pepperoni pizza

18. "I always use boxed cake mix. It's convenient and it always comes out well. You don't have to worry about precise measurements for all those dry ingredients. Plus, with the time saved by using a boxed mix, you can make your own frosting (since that stuff tastes so much better than the canned junk)."

Cake mix in a bowl

19. "It is completely justifiable to break up with someone who is an excessively picky eater."

20. "The shape of the pasta affects the taste of the sauce, and that's just a fact."

Farfalle pasta in sauce with sausage

21. "That hard part of lettuce is disgusting. I will sit and deconstruct a salad to get all the hard middle pieces out. I hate the texture."

Heads of iceberg lettuce

22. "Girl Scout cookies are overrated. In fact, they used to be much better...especially the Trefoils."

Boxes of Girl Scout cookies

23. "Ice cream belongs in a brioche bun, not a cone. It is so much better. This combination is popular in Sicily, where I grew up, but my American friends think I'm out of my mind when I explain this to them."

Sicilian brioche with gelato

24. "Thousand Island dressing is literally just fancy ketchup that's OK to put on salads."

A salad with dressing

25. "MSG is awesome. I put it in a saltshaker mixed 50-50 with table salt and use it in everything that calls for salt. Pure umami is a game-changing ingredient."

Instant noodles cooking in a pot

26. "I completely admit that Kraft singles are processed garbage and not 'real' cheese, but there are few things that compare to this fake stuff in a grilled cheese, deli sandwich, or cheeseburger."

Grilled cheese sandwich

27. "I prefer eating french fries without any condiments whatsoever."

French fries

28. "Too much cheese in a dish really, actually, is a thing."

Cheesy baked pasta with tomatoes

What's your polarizing food opinion that others would probably disagree with? Tell us in the comments.

Note: Some responses have been edited for length and/or clarity.