Email Link SMS X Search Clock Right Arrow Caret down Caret up Caret left Caret right Thumbs up Speech Audio on Replay Plus Minus

I Made The Miracle 2-Ingredient Bagels To See If They Were Legit

Let's see if the magic is real.

So you're trying to lead a healthy-ish life but also can't live without your morning bagel? I feel you.

Fox

Luckily, there's an easy way to solve this dilemma: the ~miracle bagel~. It's a two-ingredient recipe that's been making the rounds on Pinterest and Facebook for the past few months.

Pinterest

It's especially popular with the Weight Watchers community.

Advertisement

Advertisement

When I first heard about it, I was kind of skeptical, TBH. 🤔 But I wanted to find out if it was legit. So, I decided to make it and see for myself!

All you need is self-rising flour + low-fat Greek yogurt.

Marie Telling / BuzzFeed

There are several versions of this recipe online — they're all pretty much the same, but I used this one. If you don't have self-rising flour, or don't want to buy a gigantic bag for one recipe, you can make your own by adding baking powder and salt to all-purpose flour (recipe here).

Advertisement

Advertisement

Once you've mixed both ingredients in a bowl, you knead the dough on a floured surface.

Marie Telling / BuzzFeed

Do this for about 2–3 minutes, until it holds its shape.

Next, divide the dough in four equal parts, roll each one into a log shape, and join both ends to form a bagel.

Marie Telling / BuzzFeed

Advertisement

Advertisement

(It looks pretty easy — but I messed up the first bagel.)

Marie Telling / BuzzFeed

It was breaking apart and not looking great. But after some trial and error, I finally got it and made an OK-looking bagel. I think the trick is to not use too much flour when you roll it out and to make sure you don't roll it out too thinly.

Now, this is where I cheated a little and added two extras on top: egg wash (to give it a nice color) and sesame seeds (to give it more authentic bagel-ness.)

Marie Telling / BuzzFeed

I also wanted them to look pretty. Sue me.

Advertisement

Advertisement

Next, the recipe says to bake them at 350°F for 23 minutes, followed by 2 minutes at 500°F. I found that that wasn't long enough for mine as they didn't look anything near ready.

To be fair, my oven isn't the most reliable, so that may have been the issue.

I baked them five minutes longer and got four homemade bagels. And they looked pretty nice!

Marie Telling / BuzzFeed

Advertisement

Advertisement

But taste-wise, these didn't really taste like traditional bagels. The biggest difference came from the Greek yogurt, which gave them a tangy flavor.

Marie Telling / BuzzFeed

The texture was a bit off too. They didn't have the chewy bite I look for in a good bagel and the dough was slightly under-baked (despite the extra five minutes in the oven).

Marie Telling / BuzzFeed

I tasted one bagel right out of the oven, one half an hour later, the other ones when they had completely cooled down. The texture and taste were definitely better once the bagels had cooled down at least a little.

Advertisement

Advertisement

That said, I get the appeal. Even if they're not a perfect pass for the real deal, they still have many things going for them:

• They're pretty much foolproof. And even if you don't have any baking skills, you'd have a hard time messing them up.

• Flour + yogurt = cost barely anything.

• They're only 3 SmartPoints on Weight Watchers.

• They don't take more than 45 minutes to make from start to finish.

• And you don't even have to leave home!

Advertisement

Advertisement

So, are these things my new favorite bagels? No. But they'd make pretty decent bread rolls. And you can't really expect authentic bagel quality at home with only two ingredients involved.

Also, I had one with Nutella, and it was downright delicious. (Yes, I know that defeats the purpose of healthy-ish bagels, but it was worth it.)

Marie Telling / BuzzFeed

Tasty's Holiday Recipes

From easy classics to festive new favorites, you'll find them all here.

Advertisement

Advertisement

TRENDING RECIPES

Advertisement

Advertisement

LATEST TASTY GUIDES

18 Latin American Side Dishes You Should Absolutely Try This Holiday Season
12 Unexpected Things You Should Be Doing To Your Eggs
35 Brilliant Holiday Hacks That'll Make You Say, "Why Didn't I Know About These Sooner?"

Advertisement

Advertisement

17 Egg-Cooking Hacks That Are Borderline Genius
My Extremely Opinionated Grandma Rated Popular Trader Joe's Snacks, And She Did Not Hold Back
23 Most Glorious Balls Of Cheese You've Ever Seen

Advertisement

Advertisement

I Learned How To Make A Ton Of Cocktails During Quarantine; Here Are My 6 Absolute Favorites
15 Fresh Spring Dinners You Can Make In A Slow Cooker
People Around The World Are Sharing The Dish You Absolutely Must Try In Their Country

Advertisement

Advertisement

Tasty's Holiday Recipes

From easy classics to festive new favorites, you'll find them all here.

Advertisement

Advertisement

Share on Pinterest Share on Pinterest Pinterest Pinterest Share on Facebook Share on Facebook Share on Email Share on Email More More